Several drinks later, Safford talked proprietor William Young into resuming their running dice game. As usually happened, Safford fell far behind as he continually lost to Young. Finally, he accused Young of cheating and demanded that the dice be rolled again for the current stake. When Young refused, Safford hit him, made a grab at the money, stepped away from the bar where the game was being played and drew a pistol. From behind the bar, Young did the same. Each man fired five shots. Two bullets hit Safford and he fell dead. One shot seriously injured Young, whose luck held out. He recovered and a jury found him not guilty of murder due to self defense. Safford had many relatives in the Klamath area. The newspaper account of the shooting suggested that the people of Crescent City bore some responsibility for Safford’s death by allowing gambling in the community.
Source: Nuss, Sandy. Reflections of Del Norte County. Crescent City, Calif.: Del Norte County Historical Society, 2013. Print.