Shootings In Newtown, Conn.
2:11 am
Sat December 14, 2013

A Grieving Newtown Mother's Motto: 'Love Wins'

Originally published on Tue December 17, 2013 9:31 pm

As much as Dec. 14 will forever be a day of unfathomable grief for Nelba Márquez-Greene, Dec. 13 will be one of unending gratitude.

"I will never forget that day," she says.

On that day, Márquez-Greene stopped the usual frantic drill: rushing to activities and errands, worrying about the dishes and laundry, even cleaning up the mess on the floor.

That morning, her 6-year-old daughter, Ana Grace, had knocked down the entire nativity set off the piano. Baby Jesus was still in little pieces on the floor when she came home from Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn.

Márquez-Greene can't explain it, but something compelled her that evening to just ignore it all and instead corral Ana, her son Isaiah and her husband Jimmy into the car.

"And off we went to the Cheesecake Factory," she says, "where we had our final time as a family of four."

It was, she says, the greatest gift.

"We were sitting there taking goofy pictures, Ana was making faces," she says. "We had second dessert. We had, like, three pasta dishes. I'm so grateful we had that."

After the shooting the next morning, where Ana and 25 others were killed, her parents wondered how they'd ever feel whole again.

Most days still bring unbearable pain. But as Márquez-Greene puts it, she's "made it her business" to stay focused on the good days with Ana.

"It is what brings me great comfort and great joy," she says. "And that is what gives us strength."

'Our Greatest Victory'

Márquez-Greene is a therapist who's spent a career counseling mentally ill and troubled young people. But she says she'll never understand what drove a young man to take the life of her little girl and 25 others.

"At the end of the day, I don't know why this happened," she says. "I didn't get to choose it. But I get to choose my response now. I do get to choose now."

After the shooting, Márquez-Greene put her therapy practice on hold to work instead on a more macro scale — to prevent violence and promote healing.

On Dec. 2, 500 people packed a conference for the Ana Grace Project, aimed at building community, connections and compassion. As Márquez-Greene sees it, these qualities are the antidote is to the kind of isolation that always seems to be the story of deranged mass shooters.

"People say to me, 'I can't believe what that monster did to your baby!' Well, you know, it's true something terrible happened to Ana, and that was a terrible day," Márquez-Greene says. "But if we even use that language, 'monster,' if we talk like that, we already make a separation between us and them. And it doesn't work that way."

Márquez-Greene says her own compassion continues to be tested — like at her conference, when she was setting up a candle for each of the lives lost on Dec. 14. She thought of the shooter, who killed himself, and his mother, who he also killed.

"Do we have a table with 26 candles, or do we have a table with 28?" she says. "We put 28, because at the end of the day, it's a gesture of the compassion that we need to move forward."

Ana's brother Isaiah opened the conference with a solo performance.

"To see Isaiah sitting at that piano by himself was both majestic and heartbreaking," Márquez-Greene says, "because he should not be at that piano by himself."

After the trauma of Dec. 14, Márquez-Greene knows all too well that her son now counts among those at-risk youth in need of the stronger connections she's trying to build.

"That is my job on the planet. If I do nothing else but raise a son who is able to survive this tragedy and still come out able to love and receive love from others, that will be our greatest victory," she says.

Music And Love

But it's hard. Most days, she says, she feels like she's hanging off the edge of a cliff.

Her husband Jimmy, a jazz musician, just recently managed to get back on stage again. He's written a song for Ana named "Last Summer."

Music, Márquez-Greene says, brings back the highs and buoys them through the lows — like that awful day they laid their daughter to rest.

"That day was — I still have hard time talking about," she says. "But when they were lowering her casket into ground, and the weeping was just so loud, my husband began to sing.

Last summer, Jimmy Greene and his old friend, Harry Connick Jr., recorded a song for Ana, based on what became the family's motto after the shooting: Love wins.

"I don't even remember how it all got started; I just remember it just became a chant in our house shortly after the shooting. We just needed to keep Ana alive. We needed to keep her spirit with us," Márquez-Greene says. "Love wins. This is what we taught her: to honor, to praise, to be loving. And I am raising two loving, connected, compassionate children.

"And I just realized I just said, 'I am raising.' It's hard, I still vacillate between present and past tense."

Perhaps, she says, because it's only been a year. But it must also be because of the way she keeps the good memories of those days like Dec. 13.

As she likes to say, they want to remember Ana's life twice as loudly as her death.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

Today marks one year since one of the deadliest mass shootings in U.S. history, when a gunman burst into Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut and killed 20 children and six adults before he killed himself. Many of the families in Newtown have tried to put their grief into various efforts to prevent a similar tragedy in the future. NPR's Tovia Smith visited with the mother of a 6-year-old girl named Ana Grace who was killed one year ago.

TOVIA SMITH, BYLINE: As much as December 14th will forever be a day of unfathomable grief for Nelba Marquez-Greene, the 13th, she says, will be one of unending gratitude.

NELBA MARQUEZ-GREENE: I remember that day. I will never forget that day. We stopped.

SMITH: Stopped, Marquez-Greene says, the usual frantic drill - rushing from kids' activities to errands. They stopped worrying about the dishes and laundry and even the mess on the floor.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: On December 13th in the morning, Ana had knocked down the entire nativity set off of the piano. And baby Jesus was still crushed up in little pieces on the floor when she came from school December 13th.

SMITH: Marquez-Greene can't explain it, but something impelled her that day to just ignore that all and instead corral Ana, her son Isaiah, and her husband Jimmy into the car.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: And off we went to the Cheesecake Factory, where had our final time as family of four.

SMITH: It was, she says, the greatest gift.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: We're sitting there taking goofy pictures. Ana was making faces. You know, we had second dessert. We had, like, three pasta dishes. I'm so grateful we had that.

SMITH: After the shooting the next morning that killed Ana, her parents wondered how they'd ever again feel whole. Most days still bring unbearable pain. But as Marquez-Greene puts it, she's made it her business to stay focused on the good days with Ana.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: It's what brings me great comfort and great joy, and that is what gives strength. I want to play you something before you stop - it's my kids singing.

SMITH: Marquez-Greene clicks on a video of a precocious little Ana at the piano with her big brother.

(SOUNDBITE OF RECORDING)

ANA GRACE MARQUEZ-GREENE: (Singing) Come now almighty king...

SMITH: Even as a therapist who's spent a career counseling mentally ill and troubled young people, Marquez-Greene says she'll never understand what drove a young man to take the life of her little girl and 25 others.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: At end of day, I don't know why this happened. And I didn't get to choose it. But I get to choose my response now. I do get to choose now. I went to my job a broken mother and said I want to do something.

SMITH: After the shooting, Marquez-Greene put her therapy practice on hold to work instead, on a more macro scale, to prevent violence and promote healing.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: The speakers you will hear today are undoubtedly some of the country's top experts in the fields of trauma, loss and resilience.

SMITH: Five hundred people packed a conference last week of the Ana Grace Project, aimed at building community, connections and compassion. As Marquez-Greene sees it, the antidote to the kind of isolation that always seems to be the story of these deranged mass shooters.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: People say to me I can't believe what that monster did to your baby. Well, you know, it's true something terrible happened to Ana. And that was a terrible day. But if we even use that language - monster - you know, if we talk like that we already make a separation between us and them. And it doesn't work that way.

SMITH: Marquez-Greene says her own compassion continues to be tested, like at her conference when she was setting up a candle for each of the lives lost on December 14th, and she thought of the shooter and his mother, who he also killed.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: Do we have a table with 26 candles or do we have a table with 28? And we put 28 because at the end of the day it's a gesture of the compassion that we need to move forward.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

SMITH: Ana's brother Isaiah opened the conference with a solo performance.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

ISAIAH MARQUEZ-GREENE: (Playing)

MARQUEZ-GREENE: To see Isaiah sitting at that piano by himself was both majestic and heartbreaking because he should not be at that piano by himself.

SMITH: Since Isaiah lost his sister and lived the trauma of December 14th, Marquez-Greene knows all too well, that her son now counts among those at-risk youth in need of the stronger connections she's trying to build.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: That is my job on the planet. If I do nothing else but raise a son who's able to survive this tragedy and still come out able to love and receive love from others, that will be our greatest victory.

SMITH: But it isn't easy when most days, Marquez-Greene says, she feels like she's hanging off the edge of a cliff.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: I was one of those parents, probably like the parents listening at home, who said if something ever happened to my kids, I would kill myself. I would die. I wouldn't make it. Trust me. It's not easy.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

SMITH: Marquez-Greene's husband Jimmy, a jazz musician, just recently managed after nearly a year to get back on stage again.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

MARQUEZ-GREENE: My husband wrote a song for Ana named "Last Summer," and it was beautiful. Just beautiful. It was gorgeous.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

SMITH: Their music, says Marquez-Greene, brings back the highs and buoys them thru the lows, like that awful day last year when they laid their daughter to rest.

MARQUEZ-GREENE: That day was - I still have hard time talking about it. But when they were lowering her casket into ground and the weeping was just so loud, my husband began to sing. He started to sing.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "LOVE WINS")

CHORUS: (Singing) Love always wins.

JIMMY GREENE: (Singing) When a tragedy...

SMITH: Last summer, Jimmy Greene and his old friend, Harry Connick, Jr. recorded a song for Ana, based on what became the family's motto after the shooting.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "LOVE WINS")

GREENE: (Singing) Love wins...

MARQUEZ-GREENE: I don't even remember how it all got started. I just remember it just became a chant in our house shortly after the shooting. We just needed to keep Ana alive. We needed to keep spirit with us, her spirit of love and joy and dance and song.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "LOVE WINS")

GREENE: (Singing) Whenever there is tension...

MARQUEZ-GREENE: Love wins. This is what we taught her: to honor , to praise, to be loving. And I am raising two loving, connected, compassionate children. And I just realize I just said I am raising. It's hard. I still vacillate between present and past tense.

SMITH: Perhaps , says Marquez-Greene, because it's only been a year. But it must be also because of the way she keeps alive the good memories - those days like December 13th. As she likes to say: We want to remember Ana's life twice as loudly as her death.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "LOVE WINS")

CHORUS: (Singing) Your love will strengthen me.

GREENE: (Singing) Strengthen me...

SMITH: Tovia Smith, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

SIMON: This is WEEKEND EDITION from NPR News. I'm Scott Simon. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program